Third-party vendors over MSPs

Decoding the Difference: Why Choosing a Third-Party Vendor over an MSP Might Be Your Best Move

Third-party vendors over MSPs

Feeling lost in the confusing world of healthcare staffing? Don’t worry, you’re not alone! Choosing the right partner can be tricky, but it doesn’t have to be scary. Today, we’re talking about third-party vendors, awesome guides who can help you find your way to the perfect healthcare career.

They’re like travel agents, but for jobs instead of vacations! They open doors to exciting opportunities, from faraway clinics to cutting-edge labs, that you might not find elsewhere. But here’s the best part: you’re the boss! You choose the job, the location, and the schedule that works for you.

Now, like any adventure, there are some things to keep in mind. You’ll need to be organized and manage things yourself, like finding jobs and paperwork. But don’t worry, some vendors offer helpful tips and support like interview practice.

The payoff? Imagine getting the job you truly love, earning what you’re worth, and having the freedom to explore different paths. With third-party vendors, these dreams can become reality!

So, if you’re ready, consider the path of the third-party vendor. It might be a different route, but with excitement and a little preparation, it could lead you to the most rewarding healthcare career ever!

Lost in Healthcare Staffing? Finding Your Perfect Guide!

Travel Nurses Packing Tips — Here's how to do it-ORIGINNURSES.COM

Confused about healthcare staffing options? Don’t sweat it! We’ll compare two common guides: Managed Service Providers (MSPs) and third-party vendors. Each helps you find jobs, but in different ways. Let’s see which one fits you best!

Feature Managed Service Providers (MSPs) Third-Party Vendors
Service Model Pre-select assignments based on your profile Connect you with a wider range of opportunities
Focus Streamlined process, convenience Individual needs, candidate-driven approach
Control Limited control over assignment selection High control over choosing jobs, locations, schedules
Flexibility Less flexible, assignments pre-determined More flexible, you choose based on your preferences
Pay Rates Standardized rates, limited negotiation Higher potential for negotiation, market-based rates
Support Basic support (e.g., onboarding, payroll) May offer career coaching, interview prep, networking

1. Service Model:

Managed Service Providers (MSPs): These entities typically act as intermediaries between healthcare facilities and staff. They pre-select assignments based on your professional profile, aiming to match your skills and experience with the needs of healthcare institutions. This streamlined approach can save time for healthcare professionals by presenting them with relevant opportunities without extensive searching.

Third-Party Vendors: Third-party vendors cast a wider net, connecting healthcare professionals with a broader range of opportunities across various facilities and regions. Instead of pre-selecting assignments, they facilitate access to a diverse array of positions, giving professionals more choices but requiring them to be more proactive in seeking out suitable placements.

2. Focus:

Managed Service Providers (MSPs): MSPs focus on providing a simplified and convenient experience for healthcare professionals. They prioritize efficiency and ease of use, streamlining the process of finding and securing assignments.

Third-Party Vendors: Third-party vendors prioritize the individual needs and preferences of healthcare professionals. Their approach is more candidate-driven, aiming to understand each professional’s unique requirements and match them with opportunities that align with their career goals and lifestyle.

3. Control:

Managed Service Providers (MSPs): While MSPs offer convenience, they often limit the control healthcare professionals have over their assignment selection. Professionals may have less autonomy in choosing specific assignments, locations, or schedules.

Third-Party Vendors: Third-party vendors empower healthcare professionals with greater control over their career decisions. Professionals have the flexibility to select assignments that best suit their preferences, including factors such as location, shift timing, and facility type.

4. Flexibility:

Managed Service Providers (MSPs): MSPs typically provide less flexibility as assignments are predetermined based on the needs of healthcare facilities. Professionals may have limited options for tailoring assignments to their preferences.

Third-Party Vendors: Third-party vendors offer more flexibility, allowing healthcare professionals to choose assignments that align with their preferences, lifestyle, and career aspirations. This flexibility enables professionals to maintain a better work-life balance and pursue opportunities that fit their individual needs.

5. Pay Rates:

Managed Service Providers (MSPs): MSPs often offer standardized pay rates for assignments, with limited room for negotiation. While this approach provides consistency and predictability, it may result in professionals receiving rates that are not reflective of their experience or the market demand for their skills.

Third-Party Vendors: Third-party vendors typically offer higher potential for negotiation in pay rates. They may provide market-based compensation, allowing professionals to advocate for rates that better reflect their skills, experience, and the prevailing market conditions.

6. Support:

Managed Service Providers (MSPs): MSPs generally offer basic support services to healthcare professionals, such as onboarding assistance and payroll management. While these services are essential for ensuring a smooth transition into new assignments, they may not extend to additional career development or support resources.

Third-Party Vendors: Third-party vendors may offer comprehensive support beyond basic administrative tasks. This support can include career coaching, interview preparation, networking opportunities, and ongoing professional development resources. These additional services can empower healthcare professionals to advance their careers and achieve their long-term goals.

Working With MSPs

Dive Deeper:

Managed Service Providers (MSPs) play a crucial role in the healthcare staffing ecosystem, acting as intermediaries between healthcare facilities and healthcare professionals. MSPs typically operate under contractual agreements with healthcare institutions, where they manage various aspects of staffing, including recruitment, credentialing, scheduling, and compliance.

Contract Terms:

Contracts with MSPs often outline the terms of engagement, including service levels, payment structures, and duration of the agreement. Healthcare facilities may engage MSPs on a short-term or long-term basis, depending on their staffing needs. These contracts may include provisions for volume discounts, performance metrics, and termination clauses to ensure accountability and service quality.

Assignment Selection Process:

MSPs employ a systematic approach to match healthcare professionals with available assignments. They typically gather information about professionals’ skills, experience, preferences, and availability to identify suitable opportunities. Assignment selection is often based on factors such as location, specialty, shift preferences, and facility requirements. MSPs leverage technology platforms and databases to streamline the matching process and ensure efficient deployment of staff to meet client needs.

Level of Support Offered:

MSPs provide various levels of support to healthcare professionals throughout the assignment lifecycle. This support may include assistance with onboarding, credentialing, orientation, and compliance. MSPs also handle administrative tasks such as timekeeping, payroll processing, and benefits administration. Additionally, they may offer basic support services such as access to training resources, employee assistance programs, and help desk support for inquiries and issue resolution.

Pros of Working With Msps:

Convenience: MSPs simplify the staffing process for healthcare professionals by pre-selecting assignments and handling administrative tasks on their behalf.

Streamlined Process: MSPs streamline the assignment process, reducing the time and effort required for professionals to secure placements.

Access to Opportunities: MSPs provide access to a wide range of assignments across multiple healthcare facilities, enhancing professionals’ exposure to diverse work environments and patient populations.

Working With Third-Party Vendors

Unique Value Proposition:

Third-party vendors differentiate themselves by prioritizing the individual needs and preferences of healthcare professionals. Unlike MSPs, third-party vendors focus on creating a personalized experience, offering a wider network of opportunities and adopting a candidate-driven approach to staffing. They understand that each healthcare professional has unique career aspirations, lifestyle preferences, and skill sets, and they tailor their services accordingly to match professionals with the most suitable assignments.


Greater Choice: Third-party vendors provide access to a diverse array of opportunities across various healthcare facilities, specialties, and geographic locations. This extensive network allows healthcare professionals to explore different settings, expand their skill sets, and pursue assignments that align with their career goals and interests.

Higher Pay: Third-party vendors often offer higher potential for negotiation in pay rates compared to MSPs. They may leverage their market insights and relationships with healthcare facilities to secure competitive compensation packages for healthcare professionals, reflecting their experience, expertise, and demand in the market.

Negotiation Opportunities: Healthcare professionals have more flexibility to negotiate terms and conditions of their assignments when working with third-party vendors. This includes factors such as pay rates, scheduling preferences, contract duration, and benefits packages. Negotiation opportunities empower professionals to advocate for their best interests and maximize their earning potential.

Career Guidance: Third-party vendors may offer additional support services such as career coaching, resume assistance, interview preparation, and professional development resources. These services help healthcare professionals enhance their skills, advance their careers, and navigate the complexities of the job market more effectively.

Why Third-Party Vendors Are Better Than MSPs in the Health Industry?

Is Travel Nursing Worth it in 2023?

Third-party vendors have emerged as a preferred option over Managed Service Providers (MSPs) in the health industry for several compelling reasons, including control and flexibility, increased earning potential, diverse opportunities, and specialized support and guidance. 

These advantages empower healthcare professionals to tailor their careers to their preferences, achieve higher earnings, explore diverse opportunities, and receive personalized support.

Control and Flexibility:

Third-party vendors offer healthcare professionals a level of empowerment that MSPs often cannot match. Professionals have the autonomy to choose specific assignments, locations, and schedules, aligning with their career goals and personal preferences. 

For instance, a nurse might prefer working night shifts for better work-life balance, while a physician might prioritize working in underserved comm]unities. Third-party vendors facilitate these preferences, enabling professionals to take charge of their careers.

Case studies abound with examples of how this flexibility has positively impacted healthcare professionals. For instance, consider a nurse who wanted to transition from a hospital setting to working in home healthcare to spend more time with her family. 

By partnering with a third-party vendor specializing in home healthcare placements, she was able to find assignments closer to home with flexible hours, allowing her to achieve a better work-life balance without compromising her career goals.

Increased Earning Potential:

Third-party vendors often offer higher pay rates and more negotiation opportunities compared to MSPs. Concrete data and salary comparisons can illustrate this difference, showing healthcare professionals the financial benefits of choosing third-party vendors. 

Higher earnings translate to improved financial security, debt repayment, or the ability to pursue further education without financial constraints.

For example, a recent survey revealed that nurses working with third-party vendors earned an average of 15% more than those employed through MSPs. This significant difference allowed many nurses to pay off student loans faster, save for retirement, or invest in continuing education to advance their careers.

Diverse Opportunities:

Third-party vendors provide access to a wider network of facilities and specialties, offering unique or specialized assignments that may not be available through MSPs. This diversity opens up new career paths, allowing healthcare professionals to explore different specialties, settings, and skill development opportunities.

For instance, a physician assistant interested in pediatrics might have limited options within their local MSP network. However, partnering with a third-party vendor specializing in pediatric placements could offer them a plethora of opportunities to work in various pediatric clinics, hospitals, or specialty practices, enriching their career experience and broadening their skillset.

Specialized Support and Guidance:

Many third-party vendors go the extra mile by offering additional support such as career coaching, interview preparation, and networking opportunities. This personalized assistance can make a significant difference in a healthcare professional’s career trajectory.

Consider the case of a recent medical school graduate struggling to secure their desired residency program. By partnering with a third-party vendor specializing in residency placement assistance, they received personalized coaching on interview techniques, resume refinement, and networking strategies. 

As a result, they successfully landed their dream residency, kickstarting their career on the right path.

Overall, third-party vendors offer a plethora of advantages over MSPs in the health industry. 

From providing control and flexibility to offering increased earning potential, diverse opportunities, and specialized support and guidance, third-party vendors empower healthcare professionals to shape their careers according to their preferences and aspirations. 

By choosing third-party vendors, healthcare professionals can unlock a world of opportunities and maximize their potential for success in the ever-evolving healthcare landscape.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *